• Home
  • About
    • Members
    • Associate Members
  • Thematic Areas
    • Containers
    • Cruise
    • European Port Policy
    • Ports & COVID-19
  • PortStudies
  • Presentations
  • Noticeboard
  • Viewpoints
  • PortLibrary
  • PortReport
PortEconomics
  • June 1st, 2023
PortEconomics
  • Home
  • About
    • Members
    • Associate Members
  • Thematic Areas
    • Containers
    • Cruise
    • European Port Policy
    • Ports & COVID-19
  • PortStudies
    Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia

    Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia

    The strategy of the port development company: a business ecosystem perspective

    The strategy of the port development company: a business ecosystem perspective

    Circular economy indicators for ports

    Circular economy indicators for ports

    Towards a prioritization of alternative energy sources for sustainable shipping

    Towards a prioritization of alternative energy sources for sustainable shipping

    Operational productivity and financial performance: pure transhipment hubs vs gateway terminals

    Operational productivity and financial performance: pure transhipment hubs vs gateway terminals

  • Presentations
    Socio-economic impact of cruise on Thessaloniki

    Socio-economic impact of cruise on Thessaloniki

    Latest IAPH World Ports Tracker: supply chain crunch over, ports invest in infrastructure, energy transition and sustainability

    Latest IAPH World Ports Tracker: supply chain crunch over, ports invest in infrastructure, energy transition and sustainability

    Top-15 container ports in the European Union in Q3, 2023

    Top-15 container ports in the European Union in Q3, 2023

    Geographic diversification of international terminal operators

    Geographic diversification of international terminal operators

    Port integrity commitments and corruption risks in different shipping markets

    Port integrity commitments and corruption risks in different shipping markets

  • Noticeboard
    Call for Abstracts: International Academic Conference on Shipping, Sustainability & Solutions

    Call for Abstracts: International Academic Conference on Shipping, Sustainability & Solutions

    Transitions: readiness and challenges in the shipping industry

    Transitions: readiness and challenges in the shipping industry

    PortEconomics members to analyze port strategy and performance in the new global scenario

    PortEconomics members to analyze port strategy and performance in the new global scenario

    Developing China’s ports, how the gateways to economic prosperity were revived

    Developing China’s ports, how the gateways to economic prosperity were revived

    Appreciation:   PortEconomics attracted 63.006 unique visitors in 2021

    Appreciation: PortEconomics attracted 63.006 unique visitors in 2021

  • Viewpoints
    Top-15 container ports in European Union in 2022

    Top-15 container ports in European Union in 2022

    Port Connectivity; Piraeus in the global sea transport network

    Port Connectivity; Piraeus in the global sea transport network

    Deep uncertainty and decision-making in ports and shipping

    Deep uncertainty and decision-making in ports and shipping

    The 2M breakup; (how) will it affect ports?

    The 2M breakup; (how) will it affect ports?

    The future of alliances: impediments for liners involved

    The future of alliances: impediments for liners involved

  • PortLibrary
  • PortReport
Deep uncertainty and decision-making in ports and shippingEuropean Port Policy

Deep uncertainty and decision-making in ports and shipping

March 17th, 2023 European Port Policy, Featured, Thematic Area, Viewpoints

READ ALSO

Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia
Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia
The strategy of the port development company: a business ecosystem perspective
The strategy of the port development company: a business ecosystem perspective
Circular economy indicators for ports
Circular economy indicators for ports
Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia
Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia

Comment by Peter de Langen.

A UNCTAD, in its yearly flagship publication, the review of Maritime Transport, has flagged the considerable uncertainty facing shipping and ports. UNCTAD has developed four scenarios, based on key uncertainties in the geopolitical context and the COVID recovery. Broadly, based on these four scenarios, we could see a sustained recovery of international trade, an interrupted recovery (either due an intensifying war or due to continued effects of COVID-19 due to high infection levels and new variants) or a ‘derailed’ recovery, if both of the above play out. In these scenarios, the uncertainties related to fighting climate change, are not even included – though UNCTAD is very much aware of these. The DNV Maritime Forecast for 2022 is focused on these uncertainties and counts 24 different ‘future fuel mix scenarios’ with huge differences in the shares of fuels such as LNG, biofuels, methanol and ammonia. In the 2022 publication, DNV focuses on this uncertainty and does not add uncrtainties regarding trade volumes to the analysis -though they are very much aware of these.

Both reports show ports and shipping are in a period of ‘deep uncertainty’ in which there is no clarity on the direction, speed and interrelations between key drivers of change (like initiatives to curtail climate change, or geopolitical tensions) in the long-term. Decision-making on infrastructure systems is very difficult when faced with deep uncertainty. The ‘traditional approach’ of predicting and acting upon such a prediction is not effective. Instead there is a need to acknowledge uncertainty, focus on robustness of (investment) decisions in different scenarios and ‘monitor and adapt’ as external events unfold.

However, this is easier said than done, especially for port development projects, because such projects generally are ‘contested projects’ in the sense that some stakeholders are highly in favor while other stakeholders are fiercely opposed. Given the deep uncertainty, the often advocated stakeholder involvement approach of seeking to create agreement regarding assumptions (like for instance demand growth or energy needs) is increasingly problematic. That may imply that contested projects can only be executed if stakeholders can reach an agreement on decisions (i.e. whether and how to expand a port and with which kinds to policies to mitigate societal impacts).

Feel free to share

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest
Next article Operational productivity and financial performance: pure transhipment hubs vs gateway terminals
Previous article The 2M breakup; (how) will it affect ports?

Peter de Langen

Dr. Peter de Langen is the owner and principal consultant of Ports & Logistics Advisory, based in Malaga, Spain and established in 2013. Peter de Langen is part-time professor at Copenhagen Business School and held a part-time position as professor Cargo Transport & Logistics, at Eindhoven University of Technology, from 2009 to 2016, From 2007 to 2013, Peter worked at Port of Rotterdam Authority (PoR), department Corporate Strategy as senior advisor. From 1997 to 2007, he worked at Erasmus University Rotterdam (EUR). Peter is co-director of the knowledge dissemination platform www.porteconomics.eu, co-organiser of conferences and training events and regular speaker at industry conferences on ports and shipping.

Related Posts

Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia Featured

Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia

Top-15 container ports in European Union in 2022 Category

Top-15 container ports in European Union in 2022

Port Connectivity; Piraeus in the global sea transport network Category

Port Connectivity; Piraeus in the global sea transport network

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Weekly Timeline
May 24th 7:04 AM
Featured

Innovation ecosystems in ports: a comparative analysis of Rotterdam and Valencia

May 17th 11:34 AM
Category

Top-15 container ports in European Union in 2022

May 17th 1:19 AM
Category

Port Connectivity; Piraeus in the global sea transport network

Apr 27th 12:17 PM
Category

The strategy of the port development company: a business ecosystem perspective

Apr 27th 11:10 AM
Category

Socio-economic impact of cruise on Thessaloniki

Tweets by @PortEconomics
  • Containers
  • Cruise
  • EPP
  • Ports & COVID-19
  • Back to top
About PortEconomics

PortEconomics is a web-based initiative aiming to advance knowledge exchange on seaport studies. Established by maritime economists affiliated to academic institutions in Belgium, Greece and the Netherlands. It provides freely accessible research, education, information, and network-building material on critical issues of port economics, management and policies.

Additional Information
  • About
  • Login
  • Register
  • Edit Profile
  • Privacy policy
  • Contact us
  • PortProfessionals
  • PortReport Series
© PortEconomics 2020. All rights reserved.
Produced by PortEconomics