• Home
  • About
    • Members
    • Associate Members
  • Thematic Areas
    • Containers
    • Cruise
    • European Port Policy
    • Ports & COVID-19
  • PortStudies
  • Presentations
  • Noticeboard
  • Viewpoints
  • PortLibrary
  • PortReport
PortEconomics
  • April 14th, 2021
PortEconomics
  • Home
  • About
    • Members
    • Associate Members
  • Thematic Areas
    • Containers
    • Cruise
    • European Port Policy
    • Ports & COVID-19
  • PortStudies
    Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation?

    Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation?

    Determinants of sustainability reporting in the present institutional context: the case of port managing bodies

    Determinants of sustainability reporting in the present institutional context: the case of port managing bodies

    Drivers for migration of an intermodal network hub from a port to an inland terminal

    Drivers for migration of an intermodal network hub from a port to an inland terminal

    An energy consumption approach to estimate air emission reductions in container shipping

    An energy consumption approach to estimate air emission reductions in container shipping

    An analysis of the CSR portfolio of cruise shipping lines

    An analysis of the CSR portfolio of cruise shipping lines

  • Presentations
    Future scenarios for maritime transport in Europe

    Future scenarios for maritime transport in Europe

    Comparing onsite and offsite rail access for dry port developments: a benchmark study in China

    Comparing onsite and offsite rail access for dry port developments: a benchmark study in China

    GREPORT 2020: all about Greek ports

    GREPORT 2020: all about Greek ports

    Liner shipping, containerisation and mega carriers: structural changes for industry operators

    Liner shipping, containerisation and mega carriers: structural changes for industry operators

    The correlation between the behaviour of ports and freight rates in Latin America and the Caribbean during the COVID19 pandemic

    The correlation between the behaviour of ports and freight rates in Latin America and the Caribbean during the COVID19 pandemic

  • Noticeboard
    PhD Opportunity: Maritime Economics-Emission control areas & French Med Ports

    PhD Opportunity: Maritime Economics-Emission control areas & French Med Ports

    Resilience & adaptability of shipping, ports & supply chains to internal & external shocks

    Resilience & adaptability of shipping, ports & supply chains to internal & external shocks

    Lloyd’s maritime academy certificate in port economics by P. de Langen

    Lloyd’s maritime academy certificate in port economics by P. de Langen

    PortEconomics members leading role in the International Association of Maritime Economists (IAME) reconfirmed

    PortEconomics members leading role in the International Association of Maritime Economists (IAME) reconfirmed

    New book: towards a better port industry

    New book: towards a better port industry

  • Viewpoints
    The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger

    The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger

    Port clusters' social licence to operate

    Port clusters' social licence to operate

    The Analyst: a strategic plan, it may tick all the boxes but is it radical enough?

    The Analyst: a strategic plan, it may tick all the boxes but is it radical enough?

    Academic perspectives on the feasibility of mega container ships

    Academic perspectives on the feasibility of mega container ships

    The Analyst: e-commerce, service differentiation and port operations

    The Analyst: e-commerce, service differentiation and port operations

  • PortLibrary
  • PortReport
The Analyst: a strategic plan, it may tick all the boxes but is it radical enough?
European Port Policy

The Analyst: a strategic plan, it may tick all the boxes but is it radical enough?

February 23rd, 2021 European Port Policy, Featured, Viewpoints

READ ALSO

The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger
The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger
What drives ports around the world to adopt air emissions abatement measures?
What drives ports around the world to adopt air emissions abatement measures?
The Analyst: e-commerce, service differentiation and port operations
The Analyst: e-commerce, service differentiation and port operations
Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation?
Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation?

By Peter de Langen

The French Haropa ports, Le Havre, Rouen and Paris are steadily implementing the full merger announced over two years ago; the final step should be ready June this year. As an important part of the integration, they recently published a strategic plan until 2025.  The plan is an interesting read and clearly reflects the changed landscape in the port industry. While in 2015, Le Havre had the ambition to grow container volumes with 50%, to around 4.8 million, this plan aims for a much more modest growth of 10%, to reach 3.1. million TEU. The plan also acknowledges the inevitable decline of liquid bulk volumes, which account for around 50% of its throughput. As a consequence, the plan suggests total maritime volumes (i.e. excluding river transport) will remain fairly stable at around 90 million ton.

The strategic plan ‘ticks all the right boxes’ in the sense that the widely recognized challenges around digitalization, innovation (eco)systems, sustainability and circular economy all have landed in the plan. Based on my experience with strategic plans for ports, which certainly includes some mistakes, in my view the key question to ask about a strategic plan is: is it radical enough? In hindsight, most strategic plans turn out to be too much based on business as usual, even if they tick all the right boxes.

Is Haropa’s plan radical enough? Well, time will tell, I certainly do not have a crystal ball, but here are my doubts. First, like most other ports, and in line with national and EU policies, Haropa aims to increase the share of barge and rail while reducing the share of road transport. However, so far most ports have not achieved modal split targets, and in many countries the share of rail is stable or even declining. The transition to cleaner trucking is well underway and autonomous & assisted driving on the horizon. So it may be time to challenge the value of modal split ambitions.  Second, the strategic plan is mostly silent regarding the diversification of the ‘port business ecosystem’. The experience from other ports is that activities such as mega-yacht building, offshore wind, datacenters, circular manufacturing and even ‘industrial agriculture’ may be valuable additions to the port business ecosystem. Focusing commercial activities on attracting such new investments may be needed. And third, perhaps the planned transformation of the port/city interface is not radical enough and could include a stronger commercial approach to develop maritime/cruise related leisure.

If Port Strategy is still around in 2025, and I still write an opinion piece for it, I will report on ‘what really happened’ in 2025 😊.

First published @Port Strategy

Feel free to share

Facebook Twitter Google+ LinkedIn Pinterest
Next article PortGraphic: how big is the Antwerp-Zeebrugge merger?
Previous article WPSP-IAPH barometer: cargo flows impacting hinterland transport

Related Posts

Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation? Featured

Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation?

The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger Featured

The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger

Port clusters' social licence to operate Featured

Port clusters' social licence to operate

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Top-20 cruise ports in the Med, 2010-2019
https://vimeo.com/421473720?loop=1
Evolution of container volumes in European ports, 1985-2018
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=4&v=7oAfZCtiPrY
Weekly Timeline
Apr 14th 6:47 PM
Featured

Port system evolution in Ecuador: migration, location splitting or specialisation?

Apr 9th 8:20 AM
Featured

The Analyst: further steps needed for new merger

Apr 1st 11:15 AM
Featured

Port clusters’ social licence to operate

Mar 28th 4:23 PM
Thematic Area

Venice move a reminder that going green is key for cruising

Mar 23rd 4:03 PM
Featured

Determinants of sustainability reporting in the present institutional context: the case of port managing bodies

Tweets by @PortEconomics
  • Containers
  • Cruise
  • EPP
  • Ports & COVID-19
  • Back to top
About PortEconomics

PortEconomics is a web-based initiative aiming to advance knowledge exchange on seaport studies. Established by maritime economists affiliated to academic institutions in Belgium, Greece and the Netherlands. It provides freely accessible research, education, information, and network-building material on critical issues of port economics, management and policies.

Additional Information
  • About
  • Login
  • Register
  • Edit Profile
  • Privacy policy
  • Contact us
  • PortProfessionals
  • PortReport Series
© PortEconomics 2020. All rights reserved.
Produced by PortEconomics